An indepth look into the philosophy, theology and ideology of nature's existence and the role humans play within gloabl ecosystems.
|
|
| |
|
|
| |
Steve is the best Tutorial Leader.
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Friday, April 12, 2002
Steve, below are my final Park Entries. I wanted to thank you for a wonderful year. It has been a pleasure to be in your Tutorials and I found you to be a great person to discuss ideas with. Thank you for everything and I wish you luck with your PhD.
Parks Entry #6: Corteigh Park
Cortleigh Park is a children’s park that I regularly walk through with my girlfriend Sheryl. She and I use the park as an escape from the busy noises of her home. On cool fall nights or mid-summer evenings, we walk hand-in-hand through the small area, and enjoy the peaceful environment. Surrounded by houses and apartment buildings, Corleigh Park is a product of urban development – strategically placed to provide a sense of nature and peace in a busy suburban area.
A small paved path leads into the park and almost immediately the illusion of ‘totally natural surroundings’ is shattered due to the garbage on the ground floor. It was upsetting to see. Garbage is a product of our society, and to a point I have gotten used to seeing it, but when I feel the need to go for a walk through a park to get back to nature I find it upsetting to see it poorly treated. All along the ground pieces of trash can be seen, and what was more unfortunate was that the waste receptacles were completely empty.
Sheryl and I noticed that the trees within the center region of the park were identical. Four massive trees with trunks that were too large to hug and branches too thin to climb, raised my suspicions. Could these trees have been planted specifically because the have characteristics that almost make them impossible to climb? The city may have planted those trees because they are aesthetically pleasing, but I have a feeling that they were also there to prevent potential lawsuits.
Sitting on a bench overlooking the park, Sheryl and I discussed how the park made us feel. Sheryl commented on the poor state of the jungle gym. Covered in spray paint and appearing rusty, it did not look as secure as it probably should have.
I commented on the shrubs that outlined the park area. There was no particular pattern, as we have seen in past park entries. There was an area that was unkempt, and appeared to be a messy excuse to hide a house. Residing next door, though, was a house that had three large evergreens with shaved bottom-halves of their trunks that not only looked neat and modern, but also was a stark contrast to its messy neighbour.
Sheryl and I agreed that the park did not look like a natural occurrence. The hand of man could be seen in every aspect of the park. But despite these observations, she and I still enjoyed ourselves and we will not hesitate to venture back to the park again in the near future when we need a break from the family or just as an excuse to spend some peaceful time together.
Park Entry # 7: Alexander Muir Memorial Gardens
My friend Jody and I took our dogs for a long stroll through Alexander Muir Memorial Park. This park was very modern. Modelled after the Victorian Period, I found it to be very beautiful. There was a walkway that led down into the park that was made of red gravel. On either side of the path, there were orderly arranged bushes that were in straight line square formation – resembling a maze garden typically found in a seventeenth century English garden. Continuing along the pathway, there were pillars that stood protectively over a staircase leading down into a small field. At the bottom of the stone stairway, the red gravel path continued on into a less groomed dirt pathway.
Before Jody and I resumed our walk down the stairway, we relaxed and took note of our surroundings. He and I discussed our feelings and thoughts that we were having due to the influence the garden we were within. Sitting on a nearby bench, Jody mentioned that he liked the layout of the park – the slimness and length that it had, rather than a large wide park that does not extend past the human range of sight. I commented on the fact that I thought the modern garden was beautiful. The ground floor was in a chequered formation with half the squares grass, and the other half made of stone.
With our dogs off their leash, running in all directions, obviously having a wonderful time, it made me think of Descarte and the terrible tests he used to perform on live animals. He believed that animals didn’t quantify pain, pleasure, and feeling at all and were therefore good subjects for dissection and laboratory testing. He used to perform live surgeries on dogs to see their internal organs in action.
When I first learned of this I almost became sick to my stomach. I am a dog person and I have grown up with dogs in my household, and I have learned that although these animals don’t feel emotions in the same way as humans do, they defiantly have some type of emotional responses. Happiness. depression, loneliness – these feelings may not exactly fit into ‘doggy’ terms, but watching my dog running with her tongue hanging out of her mouth, barking, rolling in the mud, and playfully growling at me made it very clear that she was feeling the equivalent of happiness for a dog.
This line of reasoning, brought up another subject. If 400 years ago, our top minds belived that animals did not feel pain or pleaure – and now we know that not to be the case – then 400 years from now, are our children going to look sickly upon us for not noticing the pain and pleasure of the planet’s plant life? We have identified trees as life, but we believe that they do not experience pain or pleasure, because they don’t pain or pleasure centres. Therefore, we can cut them open and while living, we can dissect them and ‘see how they tick.’
I fail to see how this is any different from the animal experiments conducted. In 400 years from now we are bound to identify our ignorance and we will see how foolish we have been because we will realize that not only did we kill a life form that sustains our globe, but we were causing the unnecessary pain and suffering of a being that simply quantifies plain and pleasure differently.
This is what I was thinking while Jody and I, and our dogs, were roaming through the park. Surrounded by man-made beauty I was wondering if we’d ever realize what kind of pain we were unleashing upon the natural realm.
Park Entry #8: Blythwood Park
Jody and I continued our walk through the park, and we came upon a path that led us further into the depths of this park region. We left a clean, orderly, majestic area and entered onto a rugged trail that was more natural and less groomed. The path did not have any gravel to lay a clear path through the trees and plants, but was a typical dirt, muddy path laid with roots and fallen branches.
The transition from a Victorian Style garden, to a dirt path swerving through a mess of trees caused me to consider which I enjoyed more. My answer was dependant upon the time of day and my present company. I have come to understand that all forms of gardens are, in my mind, beautiful. They each serve a purpose and each is unique in the power it has over the human mind and body. For instance, the gardens that I was currently roaming through - the Victorian style had more appeal to me during the night. It was comfortable and gave way to an open sky that would be perfect for stargazing. It would be peaceful and a good place to romance my girlfriend; however, during the day it did not hold as much appeal to me as, say, the dirt path I was currently trudging along.
This area had more of an adventurous atmosphere to it. I couldn’t see very far ahead of me and the path was not easy walking. I felt more distant from my everyday life, and I really enjoyed being surrounded by nature. It was the exact place that I would want to be with my friend Jody, and not my girlfriend because it was not romantic in the slightest and we were forced to walk single file (and I don’t want to be on a long walk with my girlfriend if I can’t hold her hand).
At night, this trail would be frightening. The darkness alone would be scary, but without being able to see where I was going and not knowing what was in front of me – and especially looking up to find no moon and no stars – this is a recipe for a horror film. In reality I know there would not be any real danger, but I guess cultural influences like movies and scary stories, have made the darkness in a forest and eerie place to be.if
Continuing along the path, we past under a bridge, a hill full of strangely shaped trees, and a ravine that was made of concrete. More importantly though, we came upon strangers who, like us, were walking their dogs through this park. The smiles on their faces, and the joy they had simply by being in a park on a warm afternoon with their dogs made me see the importance of a peaceful place in such a modern busy area. People really do yearn for an area where they can be away from their man-made lives, and get back to a place where things are beautiful and simple – creation that was out of the hands of man and left to someone else. Maybe not everybody enjoys a walk through a garden and probably most people don’t have time to get away from technologically advanced living spaces, but for many people, getting a chance to step away from their busy lives and to take note of the world around them, not only holds a power over their hearts, but brings a peace to their minds as well.
4/12/2002
Monday, March 25, 2002
To make things much simpler, I have included my blog and journal entry in one posting.
The Pearly Gates of Cyberspace
I found this reading to be crude. Wertheim is obviously not a diplomatic writer, and initially this caused me some discomfort, and by the end of the reading I was just turned off.
I thought the comparison of Cyberspace to Heaven was very interesting. Part of the enjoyment of the net is that you are in control of how others perceive you, and judgements are made according to your words and not your looks. As well, this ties into our previous lectures on perception of space – and how we conceive the internet:
“Indeed, many cyber-enthusiasts would have us believe that the Net dissolved the very barriers of nationality, race, and gender, ‘elevating’ everybody equally to the digital dream.”
The constant mentioning of the Roman empire and how it is similar to the American nation was very insightful. I had learned that the Roman empire lost its power when it had reached the peak of conquering its fellow nations, and with nothing left to conquer, it dissipated. What I didn’t know was that religious exploration took place at the end of its ruling years and that the populace was searching for a deeper divine connection.
The article then, for me, took a turn for the worse and became very crude. Werheim says things like people won’t notice the fullness of her chest, and Christianity posits no gender-specific covenants like Judaism. I won’t get into the details about why the relation to Judaism was wrongly associated because it is a touchy subject and I don’t want to have that sort of debate online. But suffice to say, the comparison was a lousy one, the information about Jewish ideals was lacking in full details, and the comments were on the border of being offensive.
Better to not mention religious interpretation, unless a full explanation is going to accompany the reasoning. Otherwise a false impression can be made and in an intellectual paper, misleading is almost a crime.
Question:
If we were able to download are beings into a computer, and live forever in cyberspace, would this be an acceptable alternative to ascending into the heavens?
Journal Entry
The idea of space and the way we perceive our environment has been on my mind for the past few weeks. I have always been an observer of my surroundings, but now that I have had a few lectures on the subject, the idea of truly looking at my reality has been ever present. Inspired by this new ‘looking’ habit, I have taken the opportunity to change my present reality to resemble nature more closely. Meaning, I remodelled my Windows XP. There was not much I could do because I already have painting and plants and music and smells, that resemble nature and the space I want to be a part of, so I downloaded a program called WindowsBlinds and remodelled my desktop.
A background of an ocean, an animated START button and a sky-picture behind my programs, and I am one step closer to actually being in nature. It’s all about manipulating your space.
3/25/2002
Sunday, March 17, 2002
Silence and the Notion of the Commons
I thought that this reading was very interesting, although I thought the main ideas presented revolved less around the idea of silence and more around sound manipulation. In a stadium, in an elevator - sound being used to instill certain feelings or emotions: “Many of such background activities are intentionally manipulative.”
When the topic was on silence, I found that schizophonia, separating the sound from the source, through technological means, to be very interesting. As a hobby, I have computer programs that allow me to manipulate sound waves and alter them as I please, and to know that I am in some way altering their natural soundscape fills me with a sense of ‘futuristic abilities’ – as though we actually have some technology worthy of the 21st century.
Here was my favourite part of the reading: “What makes this domain [the silence of contemplation] distinct, is that silence is an enabling condition that opens up the possibility of unprogrammed, unplanned and unprogrammable happenings.” This led into the notion of the commons - ‘common silence’, the strength of collective silence.
The reading explains that theirs a connection amongst a group of people praying in silence, or just being together in silence. That people begin to feel what the people around them are feeling and a special connection is made. When I studied the sociology of religion we discussed the notion of group spirituality, and how groups praying together obtain more of a diving ‘feeling’ than when praying in solitary. This idea has been carried over into group silence, and although I can see the parallel, the article also left me with the feeling like it was stretching – looking for a connection that wasn’t there.
Question:
The Notion of the Commons, does this imply a telepathic connection? Or simply a divine connection?
3/17/2002
Saturday, March 16, 2002
Journal Entry
This week, I wanted to do some catching up. I haven’t made a journal entry in a few weeks now because I have been extremely busy with school and essays and tests, but now I have a little time to talk about the garden. What’s been on my mind is the essay I have just finished for ENV 321. It was about the Romanticism period (late 18th century) and the garden that was being developed and explored during that time frame.
I found that writing the essay was more difficult then I thought it would be because I wanted to keep the information interesting and I tried not to overlap too much. I was presented with the opportunity to repeat myself throughout the paper, and when trying to meet a certain amount of words, repetition is sometimes the only way to go. For this paper, I chose rather to repeat less, and therefore have less content, and I aimed for quality.
The most interesting point that I learned while writing this paper was that landscape design was based off of paintings created from the imagination. Artists were expressing themselves, and attempting to represent nature in new and exciting ways, and those images were then taken and brought to life. I had always thought that garden design was something created from the imagination, but what I didn’t know was that artists painting large canvases, attempting to use colour and shadow to express emotion and feeling, were the inspiration for garden design. These paintings brought down the walls of the conservative garden, and made way for new and beautiful gardens. What made them different from traditional gardens were their use of imported trees that were better suited for water and marsh lands, and my personal favourite was that the gardens embraced nature and tried to extenuate all of its features. For example the moon lighting, the reflection of the ponds, the sky, the wind, everything.
I would include pictures in this blog if I knew how. Anyways, the sculptures, paintings , and landscape design of the Romanticism period is quite remarkable and I'm glad I had a chance to research it for an essay.
3/16/2002
Wednesday, March 06, 2002
Parks Entry #5: Seaton Park
On our group’s third and final walk through the parks, we stumbled into a more pastoral setting. This park was not so much of a garden, but rather a setting where individuals can come to interact within nature’s boundaries. The other parks had a large variety of plant life – many species of trees, flowers, bushes, and weeds. There were bridges and benches and bodies of water to gaze at. They were the definition of what a north American garden should be – plant life set within quite surroundings.
Seaton Park was, well just a park. There were no plants other than an occasional bush and a few trees placed at random. There was mostly fields of grass and pick nick benches for lounging. This may have been a garden, but only to the trained eye. To the common citizen, it was a park meant for riding bikes, walking dogs and playing ball with no plants to interfere with the fun.
Another difference were the streets and buildings on the horizon. With the other parks on our group walk, the busy streets couldn’t be seen or heard from where we were, but at Seaton we could see the high rises of the Inn on the Park hotel and the tops of the Science Center. The area seemed less secluded because of this – not a place way from the world, but just below it.
The definition of a park and a garden can be seen differently by many people, depending on their culture and their understanding of ecology. From what I have learned in class, and my own biased background, I can say that these three parks have illustrated to me the difference quite clearly. Edward’s Gardens, I believe, truly was a garden. Trees strategically placed to block out the industrial world. Pathways through trees and thick plant life and bridges over water. Manmade, yes, but peaceful too.
Wilket Creek was leaning toward a park in my mind. It reminded me of a National Park – you go to look and not touch. Walking along the path and not really being able to interact with the surroundings because of the density, makes the feeling more searele. Like a dream where you can see and feel everything, yet it is all at a distance. The park still provided a feeling of peace and a place of sanctuary, just not the interactive feeling a garden is meant to instill – a place where an individual becomes a part of nature.
Seaton Park was all park. It was not a sanctuary, nor did it instill any feelings of peace. This park was meant to provide for a fun place to be active. Sports, pick-nicks, and any sort of activities outside was what this land was meant for. The roads close by was a reminder of industrial living right around the corner and the tall buildings were like over protective mothers watching their children play in the nearby backyard. A garden in theory only, in my books anyways.
3/06/2002
Park Entry #4: Wilket Creek Park
(fictional story)
My girlfriend and I were walking along the paved path in the park and as usual she was holding my hand. You can always spot couples that really enjoy each other’s company by the way they hold hands. Lovers always seem to want to embrace in one form or another. Sorry, let’s get back to what I was saying. We were strolling down the path and I began to feel a strange emotion swell in my belly. The thick brush in the foreground and the densely packed trees in the background made me feel very uncomfortable. I knew that anything could be lurking within the depths of those plants, and I’d be at the mercy of any animal that decided to jump me.
Let’s not go crazy. I knew my mind was wandering, so I brought my thoughts back to the present and my girlfriend. We were passing over a bridge and beneath us was a multicolored pond of blues, grays and greens, and a large patch of ice melting in the ponds current. This pond must be freezing I thought. With the ice melting, this body of water must be near zero degrees. Someone could fall in and drown. Worse, they’d freeze to death before they had a chance to drown!
Come back to reality please. Drown in a small pond in a park? This is getting ridiculous. What was there to be afraid of? The trees were laid out sporadically on the hill to either side of the path. There was tall brown grass – thick – and a soft refreshing breeze. There weren’t many bright colours to be seen because of the season; however, the trees and bushes held varieties of greens and browns. The area was picturesque. It looked as though it belonged in a painting.
I took my girlfriend to a bench laid just a little off the path and we sat together under a massive weeping willow. With the small stream flowing past, the hill covered in well formed trees, the sun shining and crows crowing, it was hard to believe that this was all naturally formed. “But honey” said my girlfriend, ”this isn’t natural at all. Years back a hurricane ripped all the housing out of this area and instead of repeating mistakes by rebuilding, the government decided to make a park of the whole vicinity. See the sign that says ‘Natural Regeneration Area’? That’s to let us know that this area is under control of the government and even though those plants grew freely, they are under strict supervision and could be ripped out at any time.”
Now I understood. This garden was picturesque because it was made to look that way. That ‘wild’ growth was only a façade meant to lure my thoughts away from stress and toward bliss. I was being deceived, and I liked it. I took my girlfriend by the hand and said “Honeybunch, I’ll let the government’s park division trick me anyday!”
3/06/2002
Tuesday, March 05, 2002
Park Entry # 3: Edward’s Gardens
Edward’s Gardens was not a new site for me. I have been there many times with my friends and my girlfriend to seek privacy or comfort in the peaceful surroundings. Although, this time around I noticed small details that have not come across my attention before. The first was the dried up lake. When we first entered the garden area, we walked up a path toward a manmade lake I have previously nicknamed “moonlake” for its awesome reflection of the moon at night. The lake was not in its normal state – it was lacking water and had small appeal. In fact the whole garden area had a dried up feeling to it – everything with a seemingly shrouded aura. No bright colours of any kind were to be seen. The only colour came from the bright green heads of the ducks swimming in the nearby pond.
This atmosphere was due to the season, I had rationalized, and was typical of this time of year. Stephen continued to lead our group along the garden’s path and everything seemed to me as though it was in stasis, until we reached the top of a hill and looked over the area. Everything wasn’t lifeless, it was just quite. Carefully placed trees and shrubs were growing all over the area in an arrangement that was obviously unnatural. A small rock wall containing the plants, a swerving path that was paved and purposely spread out, a massive tree with drooping limbs overhanging the plants below, and the lake carefully placed in the middle of this life – talk about the definition of cultivation.
This garden was a perfect example of a manmade nature sanctuary. Bridges to overlook the waters, waterfalls to install a peaceful state of mind, massive trees with limbs blowing in the gentle breeze, perfectly cut grass – and of course the “No Dogs Allowed” sign.
Seeing the beauty was invigorating, but noticing the human fingerprint on the area took away from nature’s power. What I mean is that the nearby trees that were too small to survive without human interaction (had rusted metal bars to keep them up) was a symbol that what we were partaking in was not a natural phenomenon, but a manmade creation meant to provide a form of entertainment for human pleasure.
This was further emphasized by the “butterfly’ park at the top of the hill. It was a small area built for children to play within. The designers were obviously trying to create a space that was entertaining for both kids and adults, with a nature theme. There were polished logs placed around a fire pit. There were oversized butterflies placed strategically around the play area. Then the words of Stephen Scharper hung in the air as we read the names marked on the path of bricks: “You look towards the horizon and see only corporate logos.”
This park was beautiful, but like I said, the human fingerprint cold easily be seen and it took away some of nature’s awe inspiring powers. Although, cultivation defiantly has some strong points. This area was so controlled that it allowed humans to interact with all the levels of the garden, whereas sometimes nature has a way of overgrowing and obstructing human play within its confides.
3/05/2002
Tuesday, February 19, 2002
Steve, the purpose of Todays Blog entries is to catch up on the one blog that I had missed (from Maureen's Lecture - Trickster Makes this World) and to enter in the upcoming blog entry on Cherry's reading. Just wanted to eliviate any confusion.
Trickster Makes This World
I found this reading to be very informative. The Trickster proverb is an extremely interesting topic. It dips into, as seen by the reading, theology, mythology, and social interaction. The story of the coyote at the beginning of the narrative, which led into the idea of the trickster was not a smooth transition I thought. The story did not portray the coyote as a mischievous form, walking on the line between good and evil. Later in the story though he find that the Coyote is the representative of a female trickster in some Native American lore.
When the story goes into detail concerning the Trickster and all his ideal abilities, the author says something very interesting: Trickster is thus the author of the great distance between heaven and earth; when he becomes the messenger of the gods it’s as if he has been enlisted to solve a problem he himself created.
Then the confidence man is mentioned. The idea that the modern day business man, or a man involved in capitalistic behaviors is the modern day trickster, is a very new idea to me. I can definitely see how the business man could fit the profile of a trickster: “If by “America” we mean the land of rootless wanderers and the free market, the land not of natives but of immigrants, the shameless land where anyone can say anything at any time, the land of opportunity and therefore opportunists, the land where individuals are allowed and even encouraged to act without regard to community, then trickster has not disappeared. “America” is his apotheosis; he’s pandemic.
Question
What is the Trickster's role in the Garden?
Nature and Art in the Garden
This reading I think encompasses the idea of the Garden very well; more-so then I have seen in many of our past readings. This course, I think, has made some connections to the environment that I would consider ‘far-fetched’, but this reading I believe hits the idea of the Garden square in the face.
I thought it very interesting to know that the Age of Ecology began after the first nuclear bomb test. When I read this part of the reading it made me wonder why humans are so typically reactionary? We claim to be so intelligent, the only beings on the face of the planet with dreams and goals for the future (for we are the only beings that know that there is a future) and yet when we accomplish our goals we are surprised. We are surprised that we have the abilities that we always knew were there. We are surprised to learn that we can accomplish our dreams. We are surprised to find that when we set out to destroy an entire city, we can.
It’s not what we know, but what are actions dictate.
We may know that destroying a civilization is totally immoral and when we act against better judgment to prove we can do it makes it seem to those observing us that we act on decisions we know to be wrong.
Thinking of these premises always leads me to a weird conclusion. Who has been around longer: the dolphin or the human? The dolphin. Then who must be more evolved? The dolphin. They have the same size brain as us and many other similarities. Who is more socially evolved – the dolphin of course. The dolphin doesn’t ever kill another member of the same species and doesn’t’ ever perform an immoral act (as determined by human standards). The dolphin is so much more advanced then us that the need to consider what is right or wrong is never an actual consideration. The need to build a device to destroy another is never even a consideration because the need to murder is never a need in the first place.
What’s the next evolution of humans? To get to a place where we are peaceful and content with ourselves and one with our surroundings. To attain bliss. To be content with our everything. To live the life of the dolphin.
Question
Why can’t humans be intelligent enough to not only recognize our potential to destroy, but to act accordingly, and therefore know that we because we have the ability doesn’t mean we should act on those abilities?
2/19/2002
|
|
| |
|
|
|